Black rifle newb, SL-8 or WS-MCR/WX-MCR or something else?..

If you get the SL8 you can purchase the G36 Magpul pmags and do a very easy and quick modification to the mag so it will work in the SL8. I have tried it and it works.

Here is the link from the other thread.

Please check out the photos in post 45. https://www.canadiangunnutz.com/foru...in-stock/page5

It shows you exactly where to Dremel your G36 pmags to fit your SL8. The mags fit nice and tight and the bolt locks back. I would like to thanks Brian46 for posting this excellent tip. No need to alter your SL8 magwell at all.
 
I provided accuracy results in Post 284 of the Templar Thread....

https://www.canadiangunnutz.com/for...pectre-LTD?p=19273371&viewfull=1#post19273371
I had a look at that thread on a couple of those pages you had posted on, the Templar sounds like a nice rifle. I'm going to have to do some more looking into that rifle.
I know it’s not in your suggested options but: buy and SKS and what you got left in ammo.

This takes care of the HK pricing and the "good when fixed" 180 plateform
The day I received my license in the mail I bought an SKS over a Mauser k98k in 2012, I should have bought the k98k, I even had the money to buy the k98k, I was young and with misguided friends... I had one, messed around, and had a blast with it but my interests have changed. I'm after a platform that can accept a AR mag because of the LAR pistol mags being able to accept 10 rounds. I also am in the market for a Ruger American Ranch 223 rifle, I'd like mags that would work cross-platform and I'd save money by having one set of mags.
I have an SL8 and its a fantastic firearm. Its accurate and fun to shoot.
Nice.
Never been an easier choice to make than this one. SL8 every day of the week. You are getting something that out of the box is reliable and accurate, superb worksmanship, trusted and reputable brand. It is also noticeably lighter recoiling (in my humble opinion).

BUT...based on your criteria, I don't think it can be adapted to take your regular AR PMAGs. I think it can be adapted for the G36 mags, but I am not well versed on that. Sticking with the OEM double stacked pinned/blocked 5 rounders is pretty cost-prohibitive (at around $100 a mag).

Also if your budget is 2K and that has no wiggle room, that may not meet your cost criteria.

WK180 - I have one and I would take the SL8 every time even though nothing has broken on my WK (yet). Mine is Generation 1.5 (original threaded non-HT CH). MCR in my opinion is just a slightly more reliable version of the WK, but by no means it is SL8 quality.

Agree with this completely and I should have thought about this possibility too. It runs similarly in price to the SL8 (slightly more) but will take the AR mags...but bullpups may not be for everyone...seems to be a like it or hate it proposition. I have one and it is super reliable and that is one firearm in which I will never relinquish ownership (never sell to anyone).
Hands down the quality aspect is huge to me. Nothing can wreck a day faster than something breaking and having to deal with that- I had a vehicle problem for a month straight, literally every Friday of that month it broke and I would have to cancel my date I had planned... she quit talking to me after the 4th time... but after she stopped picking up the phone my vehicle worked... maybe it was her?
I will have to do some digging to see if its just STANAG mags... or can take PMAGS...

I don't mind bullpups, if I could I definitely get a bull-pup type rifle. Right now I guess I'm looking for one gun to do most of it all, well enough. Down the road I could see myself getting one.
heavy but accurate and very well build. HK SL8
Another vote in favour of HK.
 
If you get the SL8 you can purchase the G36 Magpul pmags and do a very easy and quick modification to the mag so it will work in the SL8. I have tried it and it works.

Here is the link from the other thread.

Please check out the photos in post 45. https://www.canadiangunnutz.com/foru...in-stock/page5

It shows you exactly where to Dremel your G36 pmags to fit your SL8. The mags fit nice and tight and the bolt locks back. I would like to thanks Brian46 for posting this excellent tip. No need to alter your SL8 magwell at all.

I'll look into the cost of G36 mags, is there any particular source that is good for getting them? I do like the idea of having the AR mags just because 10 rounders.
 
I'll look into the cost of G36 mags, is there any particular source that is good for getting them? I do like the idea of having the AR mags just because 10 rounders.

The PMAGs are 30 rounder pinned to 5 :cool:

Pretty sure many of the retailers have the PMAGs in stock, just not listed online since they want to sell it with the rifles they are selling. TNA or Wolverine come to mind. The recent batch just came in, so I wouldn't be surprised if somebody will soon launch the Stanag adapter again. I saw a post last year when people expected the HK to be 3,500 to 4,000.
 
Last edited:
Something else: Norinco Type 97 gen 3. Add a nice AR optic and you stay within your budget. Like an Athlon Midas 1-6x24.
 
Not a terrible option, but the mag release and safety... ergonomics kind of suck in both of those areas.

It really depends what he wants to do with it. I read about the mentioned issues and it depends how much weight you put on it. There is a lot info out there about the Tavor but not much about the Type 97, the main reason being that it is not sold in the US. But it is half the price and the gen 3 is excellent. And when he says 2K, the rifle has to be a lot less than 2 K. Unless he wants to put another 1K into an optic. Personally, I would never put a cheap red dot on a 2.5K rifle but some people do it.

Yes, it feeds AR mags and 10 rounders reliably.
 
Oh gosh if your at 2k just spend whatever is needed to get an X95. You can probably find one sub 2k in this climate.

Phhhtttt ... the vast majority of X95 are priced at $2600 and up. Yes there is the odd one going for cheaper but they are pretty rare and those ones are gonna sell QUICK.
 
The PMAGs are 30 rounder pinned to 5 :cool:

Pretty sure many of the retailers have the PMAGs in stock, just not listed online since they want to sell it with the rifles they are selling. TNA or Wolverine come to mind. The recent batch just came in, so I wouldn't be surprised if somebody will soon launch the Stanag adapter again. I saw a post last year when people expected the HK to be 3,500 to 4,000.

Had a quick look, and found them! Seem more reasonably priced than an SL8 mag.

I tried the sl8 but it’s too darn big for me . I prefer the Tavor myself .

I've only held one in a shop a little while ago, I didn't mind it. But that's in the gun shop, not out in the wilderness. I've never held a Tavor, held an AUG at Bud Haynes many blue moons ago before I really knew what was what. A compact arrangement would be nice, but I'm leaning more toward traditionally styled mag up front on this one.

Something else: Norinco Type 97 gen 3. Add a nice AR optic and you stay within your budget. Like an Athlon Midas 1-6x24.

Not a terrible option, but the mag release and safety... ergonomics kind of suck in both of those areas.

Good points, again leaning more toward traditionally styled mag up front on this one. I guess it comes down to "if I can only have one"...

It really depends what he wants to do with it. I read about the mentioned issues and it depends how much weight you put on it. There is a lot info out there about the Tavor but not much about the Type 97, the main reason being that it is not sold in the US. But it is half the price and the gen 3 is excellent. And when he says 2K, the rifle has to be a lot less than 2 K. Unless he wants to put another 1K into an optic. Personally, I would never put a cheap red dot on a 2.5K rifle but some people do it.

Yes, it feeds AR mags and 10 rounders reliably.

I'm really honing in on just the rifle, optics can come later. I personally really like classic irons. As I get into more of this new pool of shooting I'll figure something out. I'm perfectly happy with irons or a cheaper scope or red dot/magnifier set up. The people I'll be shooting and training with are ex-caf with experience with AR-type platforms, not bull-pup, and I figured as a "hunting varmints" gun I'd prefer mags up front. I know you can train and get proficient on any system, but I'm sticking with the typical.

Phhhtttt ... the vast majority of X95 are priced at $2600 and up. Yes there is the odd one going for cheaper but they are pretty rare and those ones are gonna sell QUICK.

Yeah, any deals get snapped up quickly!

I'll just clarify my objective with this rifle
1x Black gun
-looking at this through the lens of:"If I could only have one"
-Non-bull pup
-Accepts AR mags
-Non-restricted (Pre C21)
-Semi-auto
-Shoots 223/5.56, 223 Wylde etc
-Quality build
-Avoiding WK-180 gen 1, and gen 2 isn't looking good either

-Budget ~2k

Use:
-Recreational paper target shooting
-Dynamic shooting sports
-shooting gophers, coyotes and wolves

Contenders:
SL8- A lot of you guys are saying its a really good rifle, A+ that's great
-Seen on sale at 2k mark
-AR mag adapter
-Proprietary mags are expensive
-Cons I can see- How long with this polymer hold up to field handling, UV rays and cold weather
-I do understand HK is a high-quality brand using higher-quality materials

WX-MCR- it's a bit better than the WK-180 series. Needs Loctite and constant checkups, maybe an aftermarket gas block.
If my life relied on this rifle I'm not sure I wouldn't meet my maker...
If all else fails option, will be investing in spare parts, would opt for spec 180?...

New additions:

Recommended from my range guy
Crusader 9/5.56 by Crusader
-I like that it is available with an interchangeable upper 9mm and 5.56 (Too bad it wasn't set up for Beretta 92 mag...)
-non-180 system
-It is above the $2k mark- but it is a two-in-one kind of rifle- more use- I like that
*Going to hunt down a thread on this guy*

Crusader Templar
-Read a few pages of the dedicated thread, seems to be a mechanically functional gun without any major hic-ups
-slightly above the $2k mark, higher quality build?

BCL Siberian
-Ticks all the boxes I think
-Aesthetically pleasing
-"Quasi 180" what's that mean?... how is this rifle functioning and will it have the pitfalls of the WK180 series
-Unreleased to the public yet, not sure how they'll hold up
-December release?.. will I be able to find one
-$1700
*Going to hunt down a thread on this guy*

My current disposition summary:

Optics can wait-I'm focused on getting a rifle first- I'll get one
Ammo- well I'll get some- obviously

Weighing the SL8, Crusader 9/5.56, BCL Siberian.
-I've been a fan of H&K for a long time, I really like this gun, but I'm implicitly biased toward European and more so German guns, they do make a great rifle. I've wanted one of these guns since I first encountered one in the firearms appraisal book about 10 years ago. I want to balance that bias and fanboy in me with the logical side of the cons of how long this polymer holds up to field handling, UV rays and cold weather.
-Crusader 9/5.56, I like the versatility of the platform, multiple calibres, and the video I watched being able to have two uppers and change the two in nearly two minutes with no fuss, A+. -I do have one handgun in 9mm already, maybe I don't need a 9mm rifle but it is cheaper to shoot 9mm over 5.56 when doing shooting exercises.
-BCL Siberian, the rifle is the middle ground, with a $1700 price point, very sleek looking but untested, the quasi 180 style has perked my concern due to the nature of problems stemming out of the MCR and WK180- will that follow into Siberian? Will I be able to snag one of these rifles up?

So I'm going to keep these things on my mind, keep engaging with the community here, keep reading the forums here, and do the deep dives. I'll be at the Edmonton gun show this weekend, I'll possibly engage with other people from vendors. At the moment the budget is basically one rifle, so I'm looking at this through the lens of "if I could only have one", this is how I came through the pistol ban. I had better background knowledge in pistols, and I knew the ones I wanted and what I liked, so I pursued the Beretta 92 and an iteration of the classic Luger. I came out of that fiasco prepared for this one.

I appreciate the comments and insight from everyone, this is helpful.
 
Hands down the quality aspect is huge to me. Nothing can wreck a day faster than something breaking and having to deal with that- I had a vehicle problem for a month straight, literally every Friday of that month it broke and I would have to cancel my date I had planned... she quit talking to me after the 4th time... but after she stopped picking up the phone my vehicle worked... maybe it was her?

Had a chuckle from reading this. Will have to say probably she wasn't "the one", unless you are a mechanic...
 
Get the x95... don't be afraid of bullpups. Same overall length as a 10.5 inch barreled ar15. Excellent ergos. Easy to fully disassemble (including barrel removal). Durable. You can't go wrong.
 
Get the x95... don't be afraid of bullpups. Same overall length as a 10.5 inch barreled ar15. Excellent ergos. Easy to fully disassemble (including barrel removal). Durable. You can't go wrong.

Only caveat on the X95...if you get a model manufactured after April 2020, almost all of the bolt assembly instructions online won't work as show as that rod has to extend much more than what is described due to a change in the assembly to support 300 BLK. Others here included myself have found this out the hard way.

The great thing about the X95 is it does not need a regular regimen of cleaning...there are online reports showing it can go over 10K rounds before it needs any kind of maintenance.
 
At the moment the budget is basically one rifle, so I'm looking at this through the lens of "if I could only have one", this is how I came through the pistol ban. I had better background knowledge in pistols, and I knew the ones I wanted and what I liked, so I pursued the Beretta 92 and an iteration of the classic Luger. I came out of that fiasco prepared for this one..

HAH. Before the ban, the wife picked up a minty M9 and I got a reasonably priced shooter grade Luger. Everyone is happy. :)
 
Only caveat on the X95...if you get a model manufactured after April 2020, almost all of the bolt assembly instructions online won't work as show as that rod has to extend much more than what is described due to a change in the assembly to support 300 BLK. Others here included myself have found this out the hard way.

The great thing about the X95 is it does not need a regular regimen of cleaning...there are online reports showing it can go over 10K rounds before it needs any kind of maintenance.

Was only tough the first time I took it apart. Can do it with my bare hands now.
 
Avoid anything BCL, for the amount their new products cost you might as well put that in a lotto ticket. The WS-MCR is lighter and wieldier, but if you want the quality, none of those options will come close to the SL8, H&K barrels are known to last well past 50k rounds suppressed on their short barrel guns when using full capacity magazines, so the odds of you frying the heavy 20 inch barrel on the SL8 anytime in your lifetime is unlikely, on that front the bolt assembly also lasts at least 20k rounds, and while odds are you will clean the weapon before it will genuinely require it, because especially unsuppressed the G36/SL8 has a ridiculously clean running bolt, the piston gums up over time but you can run it 5k without cleaning no problem... not that most people go that far.

The downsides are the weight, which does balance a bit better if you get the Hera lower with ACR stock in the future. Other downside is some people don't like how it looks.
 
Uhhhhh ..... I fear to ask how you may have been taking it apart, without using your hands?

Specifically talking about the rod in the bolt assembly. First time I had to use the rubber end of a screwdriver to gently hammer it into place to take the bolt apart. No hammering/tapping needed now. Still requires lots of force but I can do it with no tools.
 
Back
Top Bottom