Question on a Colt 1911 45acp

Allay

Member
Rating - 100%
10   0   0
Sorry about the lack of info but,
What is a new Colt 1911 in brushed stainless single stack worth???

No visible extras. Could find a colt web sight to get a model number.

Gun shop was asking $1500 after the only a few made it into Canada dance from what I have been told he might consider himself a bit of a fox.

The reason I ask is cause I got a used pistol off him that is a dud a $900 dud.
and I doubt if I'll get a refund but he might swap the guns out.

Or am I just throwing good money after bad and keep the $900 dud as a junk gun and never go back.

thx

A :bangHead:
 
PM the over-lord of all things 1911... Moderator and an all around great guy NAA.

He will know the score...

Here's my .02........

1. Likely $1,500 asking on a NIB brush stainless Colt 1911 is not far off the mark pricewise if you compare to what other NIB Colt generally sell for these days.

2. I'm not sure I'd be too set to deal with someone who'd already sold me a dud pistol. However, that said, if he'd give you a $900 credit towards the $1,500 Colt you might be able to make it work. Only the OP knows if that is a suitable trade off to him or not.

3. Wolfstrack has a good point about the Kimber.

2007-10-27_091302_1aCoffee.gif

NAA.
 
You Guys Are Great but the site / link is down

http://armseast.com/store/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=21_28

He has a couple of new Colts to give you an idea.

What do you mean the gun you bought is a dud? Do you really want to deal with this guy again?


You know what, normally I would be the first to agree, that said I think the gun was unloaded on him. He passed it on to me unknowingly. That gun is so tight it becomes a fussy feeder, but very accurate. For IDPA I needed more of a defense gun.
That Para is a culmination of older idea's that works for accuracy but made it a fussy feeder then you combine the likely hood of a high round count using FMJ military style ammo loaded for bear.(I know the history of the gun) Then it comes down to how to value a gun that shows well but has a high round count. Well it was only soft lead, target loads what customer walks into a gun shop and says I shot the frigging #### out of it and good luck it firing more than 2 rounds in a row but hey it cleans up real good.

The bottom line was in the end he did the right thing, I just took the time to show and explain to him why this gun will not do what I asked of it and what I had said to him what I wanted before I bought the gun. I showed him the extras I bought for it and that I was out about $500 in the process and was going to eat the loss. I demonstrated I wasn't some week end warrior that came in bought a gun abused it and then wanted to return it bc the wife found out how much money I spent while there was no food money to feed the kids. Most importantly up front I gave him a reasonable out. Give me a full credit towards another gun, which to is credit he did.
Would I buy from him again yes, would I buy used???
Did he try to pull a fast one?
Even if I remove the reasonable doubt I think the gun was dumped on him.

Anyway in a week or so the Colt will be coming home and I'll scramble to get it ready for the season.

thxs for your guidance

Allay
 
3. Wolfstrack has a good point about the Kimber.

I would have jumped on a Kimber in a second but in here in Ontario there's not a lot of choice where I am anyway.
I went on line and read the Kimber vs Colt thing.
I think Colt has made it pretty clear they are not interested in civilian handguns their production numbers are way down.
Is one better the other ???
Both have had quality problems.
Did I pay more for the Colt name? Hell ya about $250 cd more
But handguns are supply and demand around my parts.
This Colt was a group of 5 that got caught in 2 year a paperwork snafu at the boarder.
This Colt's fit and finish is very nice.
Kimber is now selling at big box stores (Cabala's) that and all the advertising sometimes speaks volumes, as companies get greedy quality goes down.
If I had the Kimber in front of me and I could compare fit and finish I might have an valid opinion.

The Colt Gold Cup is nothing more than a standard model that was hand finished with some add ons.
I understand Kimbers are hand finished as well.

So for me I have no brand loyalty, you have to work for my dollars every time.

So the question for me wasn't strait forward is the extra $250 worth the gunsmiths work on the Colt at the factory?

Will the way Colt vs Kimber wears on brass be a factor for my reloads?

The Colt Gold Cup is not set up to be abused (whats abuse?) so how is a Kimber set up?

At the end of the day I needed to basically walk away from $950 and dump a gun on someone to recover my loss or toss another $680 into the ring and get a higher end gun which was available.

Do I need a Kimber or Colt aka that much gun or would a CZ do???

What do I know, but I guess we'll find out, but I didn't want to be the guy that dumped a dud gun.
 
Ok, looks like I am going to be the one presenting the single-sided, un-objective and biased recommendation :bangHead: :p

Buy a Colt, as we come into this year and next its gonna be the 100 year anniversary of the 1911, most likely its gonna mean lots of companies doing their 'special runs' and all that. What remains is that like any good marketing, Colt's are going to be all the more rare because folks are gonna want to buy one, being the 'original'.

Secondly, the Colt name will always ensure a value for re-sale, that may or may not be of value, but nothing is for sure in life and sometimes when we have to sell something, isn't it nice not to have to lose too much? Heck, keep it long enough, it may even appreciate.....

Kimber good? Ya, probably, its all about what you want and what you want to pay. Do what you feel best for your situation.
 
Ok, looks like I am going to be the one presenting the single-sided, un-objective and biased recommendation :bangHead: :p

Buy a Colt, as we come into this year and next its gonna be the 100 year anniversary of the 1911, most likely its gonna mean lots of companies doing their 'special runs' and all that. What remains is that like any good marketing, Colt's are going to be all the more rare because folks are gonna want to buy one, being the 'original'.

Secondly, the Colt name will always ensure a value for re-sale, that may or may not be of value, but nothing is for sure in life and sometimes when we have to sell something, isn't it nice not to have to lose too much? Heck, keep it long enough, it may even appreciate.....

Kimber good? Ya, probably, its all about what you want and what you want to pay. Do what you feel best for your situation.


Agree fully. Mind you, I've always had a Colt 1911, (several different model and years), and always got good service from them. Personally, I would take the Colt over the others.
 
Dud or junk or project gun.
Seen hard use
Cheaper to buy new
d:h:

Some simple questions:

1: What was it
2: What was wrong with it
3: Who sold it to you
(Maybe he'll sell it at a reduced price to someone as a rebuild project if it's as fubar'd as you say it is)

PM me with the dealers name if you don't want to post it here
 
Some simple questions:

1: What was it
2: What was wrong with it
3: Who sold it to you
(Maybe he'll sell it at a reduced price to someone as a rebuild project if it's as fubar'd as you say it is)

PM me with the dealers name if you don't want to post it here

1) Para Ordinance P14-45 Limited
2) Occasionally Hammer Follows Slide when racking or using the slide release when loading. So it needs Trigger group work or replacement
3) Chamber smaller than spec or much larger than spec, loaded rounds jam and will not allow unloading, happens every 5 rounds or so. Mute point bc the feed ramp needs reworking and might have a micro fracture or flaw. Either way the barrel needs to be changed so that’s a mute point.
Only 1 of the 4 mags supplied was serviceable. Other had their springs cut too short.
I did make up a very soft lead bullet to see why it was jamming and it was a feed path thing.
The chamber was heading spacing properly so I’m leaning towards it being smaller than spec.
Lastly a less than spectacular addition of a mag well, while cutting back the grip.

4) Too heavy for IDPA as is.
To use this gun in IDPA it needed to be lightened and two mags replaced.
To be service able and safe on a range:
New barrel with feed ramp
New trigger and sear (safety problem) installed and fitted by a qualified gun smith.
I figure about $600 parts and labour to get this gun back in the game. Add that to purchase price of $950 you get $1550.
Fixed up this gun is not a $1500 dollar gun, new modern version it is $1500.
You can get the basic version of this gun for $650 nib with 2 mags
I’m not going to put a price on it bc it has zero value to me.
The shop has the right to sell it at what ever price but they have the moral obligation to be up front and inform the buyer.
The only way you would have picked up on these problems was to put a box of ammo through it even loading it you might have clued in.
People sell their problems all the time the gun shop got caught in the middle.
That’s why we have consumer laws.
I had reasonable expectations, the gun was not marked or sold “as is”, these expectations where not met.
Be able to shoot mid grade store bought ball ammo safely repetitively.
In cold weather it would not shoot more than 3 or 5 rounds without a stoppage using 4 types of store bought ammo. Also it was near impossible to rack to unload sometimes; no way a lightweight could have unload it. (Jammed solid whether the casing had jumped into the throat or the chamber was too small bc none of the ammo was out of spec. I checked with Lyman and Dillon 45acp gauge and the ammo fell out. New barrel would solve this and the feed problem.

Anyway I don’t think there is anything to add it’s a close case.
The shop did what was right and I see no need to name names.
He's a gun smith and can rebuild it if he wishes.
The other down side is I bought another for parts and accessories, but I know of a young lad who wants to dress his Para up, so I pass that gun on to him for what I paid.
But that's it no more used guns for me.
Cheers
Allay
 
Back
Top Bottom