Trust me, I know how clubs work. I also know our club gets a lot of new members from people that are walk-on shooters. When I say "walk-on", I mean people that show up on a trap or skeet day. Our outdoor rifle and indoor ranges are not open for walk-on's.
Our club has many members that will drive over an hour and pass 3 other clubs to get to our club. I'll drive over an hour to shoot at 3 different Sporting Clay courses. Why? Because they make you feel welcome when you show up.
So a friend of mine wanted to join a club that is close to where he lives. He asked about bringing some guest to shoot skeet once in a while. He was told no guest allowed, period. Well guess what, he is taking his money to a club an hour away that is more welcoming and will allow guest.
Now I understand that these are not public own gun clubs and the club directors can make their own rules. But let's face facts, if we close the memberships, cap memberships, limit or not allow walk-on's, our sport will die a slow death. If clubs want to keep up their Country Club attitude, your membership will decline as the old members die off.
If I was looking to join a club and they told me that there is a 2 year waiting list (or any waiting list for that matter), I'm taking my money elsewhere.