M1 .30 cal carbine WW2 Underwood

I got the rock ola of the EE, I knew the stock had crackes in it, just wasn't expecting that many cracks lol, I may try to find someone who can fix it
The Saginaw I did see in person and while it was expensive ($1400!) it did have some desirable features as being a S'G', having the correct flip rear sight and a type 1 barrel band
The EBay SA stock is apparently nos and is from the early 50s so is post war

Why can't you get a part refund then?
 
Price varies greatly on the carbines I find. I know what I was offered for mine and I was tempted to sell but where am I going to another to replace them. I have an Inland and 2 Pedersons. The price on the pedersons shocked me. Try finding any original condition m1 carbine and you are lucky to find one under 800 or a 1000. As anything conditions and rarity dictate price so do some homework before you buy or sell.

Original before post war upgrades?
 
Purple,

Sellers market here for USA war surplus. Oh well this is their time and some of us I'm sure had our time to make a hefty profit on other items.
 
Last edited:
SOLD $1350 seller said include sling, ammo pouch, M4 bayo, VN era scabbard. Too high I think. Maybe $1000 $1100 the most in todays market in Can. I will post pics since it's sold, for future reference.
 
Why can't you get a part refund then?

I'm not worried about it, I knew the stock had issues before I bought it and I have a replacement one on the way. I think some of the other cracks may have happened during shipping as the stock is extremely dry. I don't think it's fair to put the blame on the seller for that
The rest of the rifle is very nice, even has a rare 2rivet hand guard!
 
Ok but the only ebay SA 1953 stock I found is like over $300 CDN after exchange and ship from France. IF that's what you bought it puts your gun at $1250 without a true WW2 Stock?
 
It is the same one that I ordered but the add says that he will send two stocks for the $307 Canadian that it costs
That's just over $150 a piece, I will just have a spare one for later use or can sell it to recoup some costs
A lot of carbines (and garands) have post war stocks as that's what they got when they went to the arsenals
As long as it fits and looks good that's all I care about
 
SOLD $1350 seller said include sling, ammo pouch, M4 bayo, VN era scabbard. Too high I think. Maybe $1000 $1100 the most in todays market in Can. I will post pics since it's sold, for future reference.

Whether that price is high or reasonable is very dependant on the quality of both the rifle and the accessories. Bayonets as an example can vary considerably on make, version and condition from $50-400
 
For future reference to anyone interested. The markings O.G. stamped inside a square, is the rebuild stamp from Ogden Arsenal, Utah.

With over 6 million of them made during the war, it takes finding something pretty unique to be considered truly rare, when talking about M1 carbines. Please read up on them first ....

http://www.uscarbinecal30.com/

This Inland made receiver was one of approximately 5000 which were transferred to Rock-Ola around July 1943 ....maybe considered slightly rare as it is one of the least common transferred / lined out receivers.
7RwnzEt.jpg
 
It is the same one that I ordered but the add says that he will send two stocks for the $307 Canadian that it costs
That's just over $150 a piece, I will just have a spare one for later use or can sell it to recoup some costs
A lot of carbines (and garands) have post war stocks as that's what they got when they went to the arsenals
As long as it fits and looks good that's all I care about

I missed that, at $150 is better, you're happy that what counts.
 
For future reference to anyone interested. The markings O.G. stamped inside a square, is the rebuild stamp from Ogden Arsenal, Utah.

With over 6 million of them made during the war, it takes finding something pretty unique to be considered truly rare, when talking about M1 carbines. Please read up on them first ....

http://www.uscarbinecal30.com/

This Inland made receiver was one of approximately 5000 which were transferred to Rock-Ola around July 1943 ....maybe considered slightly rare as it is one of the least common transferred / lined out receivers.
7RwnzEt.jpg

That's an excellent website.
 
Given the information on the SN (235###X), it appears to be as indicated an Underwood receiver, 2nd Production Block. The high wood stock is correct for this model but the marking in the sling well should be either 'P-U' or 'M-U'. (Reference 'Comprehensive Guide M1 Carbine - by R.C. Larson)

As for Underwood Carbines being undesirable, I found this in the M1 Carbine Owner's Guide, by Larry L. Ruth, with Scott A. Duff, 'A frequently asked question is "Which Carbine is the best?" Initial testing at the Aberdeen Proving Ground indicated that National Postal Meter had the best overall test record for the military Carbines produced during World War II. But as far as shooting is concerned, there really is no one best military Carbine.'

The book also states 'Underwood's barrels excelled: they were the best of all in assembly and inspection, with index lines matching well on Standard Product's receivers. Their integral gas chambers were more satisfactory than swaged chambers. Underwood barrels required little straightening and gas piston and nut fit were superior.'
 
I know I beat this to death on advice for aspiring Garand builders, but get the Kuhnhausen Shop Manual on the M1 Carbine. The US Army TM on the M1 Carbine is also available as a re-print and is very useful. P.S. I have no financial relationship with Kuhnhausen, but all of his shop manuals are excellent.;)
 
Given the information on the SN (235###X), it appears to be as indicated an Underwood receiver, 2nd Production Block. The high wood stock is correct for this model but the marking in the sling well should be either 'P-U' or 'M-U'. (Reference 'Comprehensive Guide M1 Carbine - by R.C. Larson)

As for Underwood Carbines being undesirable, I found this in the M1 Carbine Owner's Guide, by Larry L. Ruth, with Scott A. Duff, 'A frequently asked question is "Which Carbine is the best?" Initial testing at the Aberdeen Proving Ground indicated that National Postal Meter had the best overall test record for the military Carbines produced during World War II. But as far as shooting is concerned, there really is no one best military Carbine.'

The book also states 'Underwood's barrels excelled: they were the best of all in assembly and inspection, with index lines matching well on Standard Product's receivers. Their integral gas chambers were more satisfactory than swaged chambers. Underwood barrels required little straightening and gas piston and nut fit were superior.'

I am pretty much confident the stock is a post war rebuild. There are no markings other then the #35 in the left side sling well possible rack #. No markings on flat are in sling well. Only O.G. in middle of stock so a replacement stock with the rest of the parts rebuild.

If this is true I wouldn't even want it at all, which puts the price in my book $800 range.

He did say a safe queen not sure what he meant as there is different interpretations of that.
 
I am pretty much confident the stock is a post war rebuild. There are no markings other then the #35 in the left side sling well possible rack #. No markings on flat are in sling well. Only O.G. in middle of stock so a replacement stock with the rest of the parts rebuild.

If this is true I wouldn't even want it at all, which puts the price in my book $800 range.

He did say a safe queen not sure what he meant as there is different interpretations of that.
'
A 75 year old military surplus rifle that is a safe queen (Ha). One of the carbines I own is an Underwood (actually stamped with a struck through 'INLAND DIV' with a 'U' above it on the receiver) and I think I've only fired it a few times in the 10 or so years I owned it, so really a safe queen with regards to my ownership. It's in great shape but I can hardly speak to it for its first 65 years.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom