Strike Industries Strike Forward Assist Update - Working
Jiffx2781, I did the same thing. I bought a couple of Strike FAs for my current builds. When I installed them I had the same results, they ratchet the BCG forward but won't release it rearward. I compared a spare milspec FA to the Strike FA as I thought it might be a difference in either the pawl or plunger. The plungers were almost identical in length but there were subtle differences in the pawl design and outer spring lengths. Since the FA was catching, I thought the cause was either the pawl itself, the pawl range of rotation or the strength of the outer spring (milspec spring was shorter). So on a lark, I took apart a milpsec FA and replaced the pawl and outer spring on the Strike FA. Low and behold it worked (BTW the Pawl Detent and the Pawl Helical Compression Spring are not interchangeable). I tried three different BCGs on both of my modified Strike FA MS uppers and they seem to work. For reference, I tried swapping the outer spring only but had mixed results as it caught my JP SPCS when I was removing the upper receiver and wouldn't let go.
Working. Replaced the Strike pawl (2) and outer spring (not shown) with milspec parts.
Reference. Image linked to AR15.com parts diagrams
(1) Forward Assist Pawl Retaining Pin
(2) Forward Assist Pawl
(3) Forward Assist Pawl Detent
(4) Forward Assist Pawl Helical Compression Spring
(5) Forward Assist Plunger