I admire Greek soldiers on ceremonial duty. As a person who owns a kilt I can't begrudge them the skirt, but whoever thought those pompoms and Cher-hair hat tassles instilled fear in an enemy or looked Sharp and Regimental should have taken the time to reconsider
Lieutenant General Sir Adrian Paul Ghislain Carton de Wiart (VC, KBE, CB, CMG, DSO)
![]()
Boer War:
Shot in stomach and groin.
WWI
Somaliland Campaign: Shot twice in the face, losing an eye and part of his ear. Recovered, returned to service.
Somme: shot through the skull and ankle
Passchendaele: shot through the hip,
Cambrai: shot through the leg
Arras: Shot through the ear (again)
Various shrapnel wounds, including severe damage to his left hand - which he amputated himself when a doctor refused to.
After the war, he commented: "Frankly, I had enjoyed the war...."
WWII
Recalled to a special appointment in the army in the autumn of 1939 (he was 59 at the time - but had spent the interwar years shooting and hunting "every day" to keep fit).
Was a Major General in the (ill conceived, ill equipped, undermanned, and ultimately futile) Nowegian campaign. Somehow managed to escape unscathed, in spite of having the aircraft he was in shot down while en-route. His cool-headedness is credited for allowing the majority of the force to hold together long enough to be evacuated.
After serving as an envoy to Yugoslavia to negotiate British aide to that country, his aircraft lost power and crashed in the Mediterranean. He swam a mile to shore where he was captured by the Italians.
After 5 escape attempts, he was chosen by the Italians as an envoy to England to negotiate a separate peace in August 1943.
Served as a special envoy to China from 1943-47.
Passed in his sleep in 1963 at the age of 83.
Hard as 10 year old Christmas candy, he is. Sweet Jesus, what a warrior.
Hard as 10 year old Christmas candy, he is. Sweet Jesus, what a warrior.
They don't have to, by themselves, slit the throat of their next meal.
There are certain triggers that affect anyone with PTSD, depending what scenario caused their trauma in the first place.
Blood, smell of burning flesh, smoke, flashes, loud sound, dead children, the list is endless.
Lieutenant General Sir Adrian Paul Ghislain Carton de Wiart (VC, KBE, CB, CMG, DSO)
![]()
Boer War:
Shot in stomach and groin.
WWI
Somaliland Campaign: Shot twice in the face, losing an eye and part of his ear. Recovered, returned to service.
Somme: shot through the skull and ankle
Passchendaele: shot through the hip,
Cambrai: shot through the leg
Arras: Shot through the ear (again)
Various shrapnel wounds, including severe damage to his left hand - which he amputated himself when a doctor refused to.
After the war, he commented: "Frankly, I had enjoyed the war...."
WWII
Recalled to a special appointment in the army in the autumn of 1939 (he was 59 at the time - but had spent the interwar years shooting and hunting "every day" to keep fit).
Was a Major General in the (ill conceived, ill equipped, undermanned, and ultimately futile) Nowegian campaign. Somehow managed to escape unscathed, in spite of having the aircraft he was in shot down while en-route. His cool-headedness is credited for allowing the majority of the force to hold together long enough to be evacuated.
After serving as an envoy to Yugoslavia to negotiate British aide to that country, his aircraft lost power and crashed in the Mediterranean. He swam a mile to shore where he was captured by the Italians.
After 5 escape attempts, he was chosen by the Italians as an envoy to England to negotiate a separate peace in August 1943.
Served as a special envoy to China from 1943-47.
Passed in his sleep in 1963 at the age of 83.
No doubt that's part of it, but it doesn't explain why such a large number of people who were tucked in safely behind the wire on the Kandahar Airfield for their entire tour have emerged to claim PTSD. I think it speaks to how and where our society has evolved where the interests of the individual have been elevated above everything else and people feel entitled to an uninterrupted life of ease and personal fulfillment.
People experienced PTSD under other labels as a result of participation in earlier wars and a lot of it was masked by things like alcoholism, family strife, mental illness and an inability to cope. I think its very fertile ground for the psychologists to examine. I doubt that more "primitive" societies experience the same levels of psychological damage in their troops. It calls up images of ancient Greece becoming soft and decadent to the point where they were overrun by a horde of Roman farm boys.
@Purple: read the book "on killing" by Lt. Col. Dave Grossmann.
The topic is quite complex and can hardly be reduced to the upbringing of the soft youth of today.
I'm less interested in seeing people insulted about PTSD than I am about seeing this issue tackled in a systematic way to improve how our military can predict, mitigate and deal with it in future conflicts.
There's a hell of a lot of work that needs to be done on this and on the issue of post-deployment/later life suicides by veterans. I have my own experiences as well as some knowledge of other's personal circumstances, but this is really meaningless in comparison to the findings of systematic clinical analysis.