Going to bump this instead of making a new thread. I want opinions on the following.
Backstory, we do the equal split with group of very differing enthusiastic levels, and hunting participation levels, with some guys basically sitting back waiting for tags to be filled, but are otherwise nice guys.
I have access to a camp in a better area and am considering it, but with a change to the meat split, instead of excluding the “nice guys” altogether.
A hunter fills a tag, that’s his meat. If nobody volunteers to tag share afterward and hunter wants to continue and is successful, tags are drawn at random, that following meat would be split 50/50 between successful hunter (already tagged out) and the tag holder. If multiple people volunteer their tag, draw to decide.
Basically the dead weight “nice guys” would be limited to 1/2 a deer if someone fills their tag, but still be welcome to join, and encouraged to participate if they want more..
Edit to add. I don’t think anyone is an ####### enough to go home with a deer or more while someone else went home with an unfilled tag. We have a hunting buddy who’s been unable to attend due to health problems, he still receives meat every year.