Shok Buffers

jackrabbit000

CGN Ultra frequent flyer
Rating - 100%
188   0   0
Location
Alberta
Anyone using shok buffers in their 1911's or any other pistol? Are these thing really needed or having the correct recoil spring is all you need?
 
Last edited:
Correct springbetter, but buffer can show wear indicating too light of a spring.

Don't need one breaking apart inside causing problems too
 
Don't need one breaking apart inside causing problems too
Yeah, I agree. I bought a Nighthawk off the EE that had one installed...it broke up during a match and jammed the gun up tight. Checked with Nighthawk the next day and they don't recommend them.
 
I never install one in my 1911, but did shoot a club member's gold cup with the buffer installed. the recoil did feel lighter. Then one or two months later, that buffer broke(not sure how long has he had it though) and he didn't bother to install one again.
the buffer itself looks very similar to the one integrated on the guide rod in HK P30, but install differently as an add-on and should work with the factory spring because the member told me that he never changed his spring.

Anyone using shok buffers in their 1911's or any other pistol? Are these thing really needed or having the correct recoil spring is all you need?
 
Exactly, if John Browning wanted one he would have invented one.

If we all had that opinion we'd be in the stone age still. Inventions are just starting points, not meant to be the final products.

We would still be chasing airplanes like the wright brothers, not commuting in a 777-300 at 35000 ft
 
Wolf makes a variable recoil spring that works great

If the buff looks like its being beaten up, the spring is too light. Should show slight wear after 1k rounds if the spring weight is correct
 
If we all had that opinion we'd be in the stone age still. Inventions are just starting points, not meant to be the final products.

We would still be chasing airplanes like the wright brothers, not commuting in a 777-300 at 35000 ft



Do you know who John Browning was? When it comes to shok buffers I remember Col Jeff Coopers words which are applicable here: "A perfect solution to a non existent problem". Also do you know who Jeff Cooper was:p
 
For no scientific reason I just run an 18.5 in my 45s. I don't shoot max loads and the guns cycle fine. Gives me some peace of mind

I've only had one where I could feel the slide battering, and the spring inside was both obviously too short, like it was for a commander (or cut down) and far too soft, like for a 9mm.
 
Do you know who John Browning was? When it comes to shok buffers I remember Col Jeff Coopers words which are applicable here: "A perfect solution to a non existent problem". Also do you know who Jeff Cooper was:p

Definitely do, but I don't need to live in the past
 
If we all had that opinion we'd be in the stone age still. Inventions are just starting points, not meant to be the final products.

We would still be chasing airplanes like the wright brothers, not commuting in a 777-300 at 35000 ft

And yet nearly all new firearms do not have them. I wonder why?

Shawn
 
If you bothered to read, that quote was for something else, not advocating shock buffs. But most post from the hip here I notice
 
If you bothered to read, that quote was for something else, not advocating shock buffs.

I did read it. And my post stands

It not my fault you cant differentiate between someone actually inventing something to solve a problem and someone seeing an opportunity to use marketing to make money off of gullible people.

But most post from the hip here I notice

You mean like the guy that compares the evolution of manned flight from the wright brothers to 777s to shock buffers?

Shawn
 
I use them in my 1911 GSG, in my 1911 Trojan, and my 1911 SAM. Also had a Walther p22 and a SIG 229 and a CZ 75B I used them in. No reason why, but always have and they have never caused me any trouble. Couldn't tell you what it was like shooting without them :) maybe someone who has bought a pistol off me could say if it's ever caused any problems.
 
For no scientific reason I just run an 18.5 in my 45s. I don't shoot max loads and the guns cycle fine. Gives me some peace of mind

I've only had one where I could feel the slide battering, and the spring inside was both obviously too short, like it was for a commander (or cut down) and far too soft, like for a 9mm.

The standard 1911 spring is 16#. A 18.5# spring might help when firing the gun and reduces the wear on the gun when the slide cycles back but you have to remember that the slide slams forward that much harder too. The reason for installing a Wilson Combat Shok Buffer was to keep the 16# spring. Changing it out every 1000 rds or checking it every time you clean it and you wouldn't have to worry about it breaking apart.
 
It not my fault you cant differentiate between someone actually inventing something to solve a problem and someone seeing an opportunity to use marketing to make money off of gullible people.



You mean like the guy that compares the evolution of manned flight from the wright brothers to 777s to shock buffers?

Shawn


Amen brother Shawn, amen. My 2000th post, where is my goat:rockOn::rockOn:
 
Back
Top Bottom