The original OP asked about good actions. When I look at your posts, you obviously have a lot of experience in precision shooting, rifles and components.
I just think for someone like yourself to disparage a product purely on a bunch of stories is disingenuous. I think for someone like George Gardner to endorse the Curtis action as one of the best on the market holds a tremendous amount of more water than a bunch of stories on the internet...
They are more then just stories, and one of my shooting buddies got not one, but two brand new Curtis Custom actions that were junk straight from the factory.
I've been hearing lot's of discouraging things about Curtis for years now, from the beginning from those that were close to the manufacturing of the actions. I was curious when it was going to start unraveling on them, and lately there's been more and more people coming out complaining about the quality of the Curtis actions. Sounds like it's gotten worse since Joel Russo left, especially the customer service side, since he was one of the only ones that would pick up a phone over there.
Sounds like you got a good one, and you are obviously very happy with it. There's others out there as well that have been perfectly happy with their Curtis experience. I see a lot of red flags being raised with Curtis Customs, and have for years. It's completely inconsequential to me what actions people buy, I don't make money off of anything firearm related. But I still can't recommend them in good faith, not with all the other great action companies out there.
I'll continue to recommend other actions over the Curtis. If people want to buy Curtis actions, that's cool, no sweat off of my back. I hope it works out for them and I hope they get great actions that they are happy with. Recommending a product that I know that has a history of issues is something that I can't do.